Beroep tegen weigering van inschrijving van woordmerk Boomerang faalt

Gerecht EU 2 oktober 2013, T-285/12 (Cartoon Network/OHMI tegen Boomerang TV (BOOMERANG) - dossier
Gemeenschapsmerk – Beroep ingesteld door de aanvrager van het woordmerk „BOOMERANG”, voor diensten van de klassen 38 en 41, strekkende tot vernietiging van beslissing R 699/20112 van de tweede kamer van beroep van het Bureau voor harmonisatie binnen de interne markt (BHIM) van 2 april 2012, waarbij is verworpen het beroep tegen de beslissing van de oppositieafdeling houdende weigering van inschrijving van dat merk in het kader van de oppositie van de houder van het gemeenschapsbeeldmerk dat de woordelementen „Boomerang TV” bevat, voor diensten van klasse 41.

Dit beroep faalt. Cartoon Network heeft niet aannemelijk kunnen maken dat er geen verwarring  zal optreden met het oudere merk van Boomerang TV S.A.

Law
56. It is clear from that case-law that, contrary to the applicant’s contention, it was required to demonstrate that the coexistence of the marks on which it relied was based on the absence of a likelihood of confusion on the part of the relevant public.

59. It is sufficient to state, as the Board of Appeal found, that that evidence relates solely to the mark applied for, but gives no indication of the way in which the relevant public encountered the conflicting marks on the market and the services for which they were used. Nor can use of the signs on the market be inferred from the national registers, and the affidavit from the applicant itself is disputable evidence which is not substantiated by additional evidence from independent sources. The Board of Appeal was therefore correct to consider that that evidence was insufficient to demonstrate the coexistence of the conflicting marks.

Costs
62. Under Article 87(2) of the Rules of Procedure of the Court, the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs if they have been applied for in the successful party’s pleadings. Since the applicant has been unsuccessful, it must be ordered to pay the costs, in accordance with form of order sought by OHIM and the intervener.

On those grounds,
THE GENERAL COURT (Seventh Chamber)
hereby:
1.      Dismisses the action;
2.      Orders The Cartoon Network, Inc. to pay the costs.